Ok, this is dangerous and difficult territory, but after 5 years of this show, I think I will hazard to predict who the top 12 finalists will be on american idol based on their performances on the first, top 24 elimination show. Let’s see if you agree. Girls (in no particular order): 1. Mandisa 2. Kellie Pickler 3. Paris Bennett 4. Lisa Tucker 5. Katharine PcPhee 6. Ayla Brown The one wild card I would throw into this is Melissa McGhee. I think she could cause an upset and possibly knock one of the other 6 out. Also, Kinnik Sky could too, but I think she is a little too mature for the audience of power voters, so I don’t think she’ll make it (though I worship her). Of course, this means, buh bye Brenna! My picks for the boys will come out after the show.
Idolfan's Early Prediction for Top 6 Girl Finalists on American Idol
Ok, this is dangerous and difficult territory, but after 5 years of this show, I think I will hazard to predict who the top 12 finalists will be on american idol based on their performances on the first, top 24 elimination show. Let’s see if you agree. Girls (in no particular order): 1. Mandisa 2. Kellie Pickler 3. Paris Bennett 4. Lisa Tucker 5. Katharine PcPhee 6. Ayla Brown The one wild card I would throw into this is Melissa McGhee. I think she could cause an upset and possibly knock one of the other 6 out. Also, Kinnik Sky could too, but I think she is a little too mature for the audience of power voters, so I don’t think she’ll make it (though I worship her). Of course, this means, buh bye Brenna! My picks for the boys will come out after the show.
Related posts: