Haley Scarnato May Be Too Mature for American Idol

This year definitely is all about the beautiful people. . . I mean really? This girls are all drop dead gorgeous. So, enter Haley Scarnato who is another natural beauty. Lets see how she does. . . She came out and gave a great performance of a fairly safe pop song – “it’s all coming back to me.” What can I say. . she was great. . but compared to the risky performances of others. . it ended up not being very memorable. Randy agreed with me, saying it was a good song choice but that she didn’t do anything special with it. Paula said she did a nice job. Simon said that the problem was sounding way too old, adding it was like the last song of the evening at a decent hotel, advising her to sound younger.

Related posts:

1. Haley Scarnato American Idol Audition