Comments on: Haley Scarnato Is Beautiful But Forgettable http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/ all american idol, all the time! Fri, 09 Jan 2009 15:10:03 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.0.5 by: freeeeringtones http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-24285 Sat, 18 Aug 2007 07:29:25 +0000 http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-24285 popular free ringtones www.thehotstop.info signature... popular free ringtones

www.thehotstop.info

signature…

]]> by: casinosfreebonusesv http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-23850 Sun, 12 Aug 2007 09:05:24 +0000 http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-23850 deposit free bonus casino see to signature... deposit free bonus casino
see to signature…

]]> by: idolfan http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-15686 Sun, 11 Mar 2007 03:24:00 +0000 http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-15686 Definitely agree, Kim. Definitely agree, Kim.

]]> by: Kim http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-15662 Fri, 09 Mar 2007 14:31:54 +0000 http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-15662 I agree with idolfan to some extent, but I also think that Haley got the sympathy vote from a lot of people because Simon is downright cruel to her. She might be cheesy and not very marketable, but she does have a nice voice, and Simon should have just said that she was cheesy and not that she was horrible, because she wasn't. He certainly made me feel sorry for her, and I think lots of other people are voting for her because she's getting a bad rap! I agree with idolfan to some extent, but I also think that Haley got the sympathy vote from a lot of people because Simon is downright cruel to her. She might be cheesy and not very marketable, but she does have a nice voice, and Simon should have just said that she was cheesy and not that she was horrible, because she wasn’t. He certainly made me feel sorry for her, and I think lots of other people are voting for her because she’s getting a bad rap!

]]> by: idolfan http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-15645 Fri, 09 Mar 2007 03:51:06 +0000 http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-15645 Nope. I don't think it's fixed. . . I just think that there are so few white girls who are decent so she got in due to affirmative action. Likewise, Sabrina was one of 4 fabulous black women and so invariably the votes got split and someone had to go. It would have been her or Stephanie. . Having watched the show every season, there are always a couple of fantastic black women that get the boot for no other reason than demographics. . .Don't get me wrong, i'm not suggesting racism. . It's just that the callers identify with certain characteristics . . so this year, Haley benefited. Nope. I don’t think it’s fixed. . . I just think that there are so few white girls who are decent so she got in due to affirmative action. Likewise, Sabrina was one of 4 fabulous black women and so invariably the votes got split and someone had to go. It would have been her or Stephanie. . Having watched the show every season, there are always a couple of fantastic black women that get the boot for no other reason than demographics. . .Don’t get me wrong, i’m not suggesting racism. . It’s just that the callers identify with certain characteristics . . so this year, Haley benefited.

]]> by: Linda http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-15640 Fri, 09 Mar 2007 02:12:08 +0000 http://idolnotes.com/modules/wordpress/2007/03/08/american-idol/haley-scarnato-is-beautiful-but-forgettable/#comment-15640 I think America doesn't know talent!!!!! Haley should have been the one voted off tonight not Sabrina. Simon was right about Haley she wants to be a singer but doesn't have the voice or passion. I was so outraged that America voted ? or is American Idol fixed? I think America doesn’t know talent!!!!! Haley should have been the one voted off tonight not Sabrina. Simon was right about Haley
she wants to be a singer but doesn’t have the voice or passion. I was so outraged that America voted ? or is American Idol fixed?

]]>